Evolution and Prospects of Compulsory Health Insurance in Russia
https://doi.org/10.18288/1994-5124-2023-1-8-33
Abstract
The paper analyzes the transformation in Russian compulsory health insurance (CHI) over the thirty years of its existence and highlights the changes in the mechanisms of state, societal and market regulation used to perform the three main functions of the healthcare financing system: i) collection of financial resources, ii) pooling and allocation of financial resources, iii) purchasing of medical care. These changes are interpreted as institutional responses to challenges in making healthcare financing operate in a stable and efficient way. The Russian CHI system has evolved from an attempt to base it on a combination of state, societal and market regulation into almost complete dominance by the state. The initially heralded creation of a competitive CHI model succumbed to practical obstacles such as the lack of market institutions in the overall economy and the time-restricted window of opportunity for implementing market reforms. This led to modifications in the design of the CHI model and to replacement of regulation by societal and market institutions with regulation by state institutions. From that point on, the government policy toward CHI has been aimed at strengthening centralized state regulation of the CHI system. The future development of the Russian CHI system will require resolving this key institutional contradiction in its design. The choices are: a) continue replacing the remaining market and societal regulatory mechanisms with administrative regulation and using the tools of the latter to ensure more sustainability and efficiency in the CHI system; or b) try strengthening market and societal regulation of the CHI system, and especially the role of health insurers, and thereby increase their impact on the effectiveness CHI. These two alternatives point to two possible scenarios for the future implementation of CHI in Russia.
Supporting agencies: This article was produced as part of a research project implemented under the Basic Research Program at the National Research University Higher School of Economics (HSE University)
About the Author
S. V. Shishkin
National Research University Higher School of
Economics
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Sergey V. Shishkin, Dr. Sci. (Econ.), Director of the Centre
Centre for Health Policy
101000; 20, Myasnitskaya ul.; Moscow
References
1. Gerasimenko N. Poverty of Health Insurance in Russia]. Ekonomika zdravookhraneniya [Healthcare Economics], 1996, special issue, pp. 2-3. (In Russ.)
2. Gontmakher E. Sh. Okhrana zdorov’ya: mirovye tendentsii i opyt Rossii [Health Protection: World Trends and the Experience of Russia]. In: Gontmakher E. Sh., Grishin I. V., Tsapenko I. P. (eds.). Sotsial’nyy kontekst ekonomicheskogo razvitiya v XXI veke [Social Context of Economic Development in the 21<sup>st</sup> Century]. Moscow, IMEMO RAN, 2016, pp. 78-92. https://www.imemo.ru/publications/info/sotsialyniy-kontekst-ekonomicheskogo-razvitiya-v-xxi-veke. (In Russ.)
3. Zharkovich G., Zattsinger V., Milk A., John U., Grishin V. V., Semenov V. Yu. Voprosy politiki v oblasti zdravookhraneniya v byvshikh sotsialisticheskikh stranakh. Strategii uluchsheniya sistem zdravookhraneniya v byvshikh sotsialisticheskikh stranakh [Health Policy Issues in Former Socialist Countries. Strategies for Improving Healthcare Systems in Former Socialist Countries]. Moscow, Federal Fund for CHI, 1998. (In Russ.)
4. Kravchenko V. V., Shatalin Ye. V. Itogi reformirovaniya sistemy OMS v 2010-2013 gg. Analiz nedostatkov sushchestvuyushchey sistemy OMS [Outcomes of Reforming the CHI System in 2010-2013. Analysis of the Shortcomings of the Existing CHI system]. Menedzher zdravookhraneniya [Health Manager], 2014, no. 3, pp. 6-19. https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/itogi-reformirovaniya-sistemy-oms-v-2010-2013-gg-analiz-nedostatkov-suschestvuyuschey-sistemy-oms. (In Russ.)
5. Kuznetsov D. OMS na pereput’e: 30 let spustya [CHI at a Crossroad: 30 Years Later]. Sovremennye strakhovye tekhnologii [Modern Insurance Technologies], 2021, no. 3. https://consult-cct.ru/oms-na-pereput-e-30-let-spustya. (In Russ.)
6. Nazarov V. S., Avksentiev N. A., Sisigina N. N. Osnovnye napravleniya razvitiya sistemy zdravookhraneniya Rossii: trendy, razvilki, stsenarii [The Main Directions of Development of the Healthcare System in Russia: Trends, Choices, Scenarios]. Moscow, Delo, 2019. (In Russ.)
7. Komarov Yu. M. (ed.). Osnovnye polozheniya strategii okhrany zdorov’ya naseleniya RF na period 20132020 gg. i posleduyushchie gody [The Main Provisions of the Strategy for Protecting the Health of the Population of the Russian Federation for the Period 20132020 and Subsequent Years]. Moscow, Civil Initiatives Committee, 2013. https://polit.ru/media/files/2013/12/25/81c8aa58d07e0615f49bd9778e4d0a34.pdf. (In Russ.)
8. Otchet o rezul’tatakh ekspertnoanaliticheskogo meropriyatiya “Analiz effektivnosti funktsionirovaniya sistemy obyazatel’nogo meditsinskogo strakhovaniya v Rossiyskoy Federatsii” [Report on the Results of the ExpertAnalytical Event “Analysis of the Effectiveness of the Functioning of the System of Compulsory Medical Insurance in the Russian Federation”]. Moscow, Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation, 2021. https://ach.gov.ru/upload/iblock/432/wjvi2beix796z4vpn04vyii4ppk4fxcr.pdf. (In Russ.)
9. Semenov V. Yu. Obyazatel’noe meditsinskoe strakhovanie i reformirovanie zdravookhraneniya v Rossii i za rubezhom [Compulsory Health Insurance and Healthcare Reform in Russia and Abroad]. Ekonomika zdravookhraneniya [Healthcare Economics], 1996, no. 4, pp. 8-15. (In Russ.)
10. Starodubov V. I. O problemakh vvedeniya meditsinskogo strakhovaniya grazhdan v Rossii [On the Problems of Introducing Health Insurance for Citizens in Russia]. Meditsinskoe strakhovanie [Health Insurance], 1992, no. 1, pp. 7-9. (In Russ.)
11. Starodubov V. I., Kadyrov F. N., Obukhova O. V., Bazarova I. N., Yendovitskaya Yu. V., Nesvetaylo N. Ya. Vliyaniye koronavirusa COVID19 na situatsiyu v rossiyskom zdravookhranenii : analiticheskiy doklad [The Impact of the COVID19 Coronavirus on the Situation in Russian Healthcare : Analytical Report]. Moscow, Russian Research Institute of Health, 2020. https://mednet.ru/images/materials/news/doklad_cniioiz_po_COVID-19-2020_04_26.pdf. (In Russ.)
12. Sheiman I. M. Kvazirynochnye otnosheniya v sisteme obshchestvennogo zdravookhraneniya [Quasi-Market Relations in the Public Health System]. In: Kolosnitsyna M. G., Sheiman I. M., Shishkin S. V. (eds.). Ekonomika zdbravookhraneniya [Economics of Healthcare], 2<sup>nd</sup> ed. Moscow, Geotar-Media, 2018, pp. 337-357. (In Russ.)
13. Sheiman I. M. Reforma upravleniya i finansirovaniya zdravookhraneniya [Healthcare Management and Financing Reform]. Moscow, Rus’, 1998. (In Russ.)
14. Shishkin S. V. Reforma finansirovaniya rossiyskogo zdravookhraneniya [Reform of Russian Healthcare Financing]. Moscow, Institute for the Economy in Transition, 2000. (In Russ.)
15. Shishkin S. V. Yavlyaetsya li strakhovoy rossiyskaya sistema obyazatel’nogo meditsinskogo strakhovaniya? [Is the Russian System of Compulsory Health Insurance a Form of Insurance?]. Voprosy ekonomiki, 2022, no. 8, pp. 32-47. (In Russ.)
16. Shishkin S. V., Ponkratova O. F. Territorial’naya differentsiatsiya tarifov na oplatu meditsinskoy pomoshchi v OMS [Territorial Differentiation of Tariffs for Payment of Medical Care in Compulsory Medical Insurance]. Voprosy gosudarstvennogo i munitsipal’nogo upravleniya [Public Administration Issues], 2021, no. 1, pp. 75-99. (In Russ.)
17. Shishkin S. V., Sheiman I. M., Potapchik E. G., Ponkratova O. F. Analiz sostoyaniya strakhovoy meditsiny v Rossii i perspektiv ee razvitiya [Analysis of the State of Health Insurance in Russia and the Prospects for Its Development]. Moscow, HSE Publishing House, 2019. https://publications.hse.ru/books/266095705. (In Russ.)
18. Alexa J., Rečka L., Votápková J., Van Ginneken E., Spranger A., Wittenbecher F. Czech Republic : Health System Review. Health Systems in Transition, 2015, vol. 17, no. 1.
19. Besstremyannaya G., Simm J. The Impact of Private Health Insurers on the Quality of Russian Regional Health Systems. Center for Economic and Financial Research at New Economic School. Working Paper, no. 177, 2012.
20. Busse R., Blümel M. Germany: Health System Review. Health Systems in Transition. 2014, vol. 16, no. 2
21. Danishevski K., Balabanova D., McKee M., Atkinson S. The Fragmentary Federation: Experiences With the Decentralized Health System in Russia. Health Policy and Planning. 2006, vol. 21, no. 3, pp. 183-194.
22. De Jong J., Brabers A. Switching Health Insurer in the Netherlands: Price Competition But Lacking Competition On Quality. Eurohealth, 2019, vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 22-25.
23. Dixon A., Pfaff M., Hermesse J. Solidarity and Competition in Social Health Insurance Countries. In: Saltman R. B., Busse R., Figueras J. (eds.). Social Health Insurance Systems in Western Europe. Maidenhead, Open University Press, 2004, pp. 170-186. http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/19957.
24. Hassenteufel P., Palier B. Towards Neo-Bismarckian Health Care States? Comparing Health Insurance Reforms in Bismarckian Welfare Systems. Social Policy & Administration, 2007, vol. 41, no. 6. pp. 574-596.
25. Health Care Systems in Transition. Switzerland. European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies, 2000.
26. Kutzin J., Cashin Ch., Jakab M. (eds.). Implementing Health Financing Reform. Lessons From Countries in Transition. World Health Organization, Regional Office for Europe. Observatory Studies Series, 2010, No 21.
27. Kroneman M., Boerma W., Van den Berg M., Groenewegen P., De Jong J., Van Ginneken E. The Netherlands: Health System Review. Health Systems in Transition, 2016, vol. 18, no. 2.
28. Kutzin J. A. Descriptive Framework for Country-Level Analysis of Health Care Financing Arrangements. Health Policy, 2001, vol. 56, no. 3, pp. 171-204.
29. Popovich L., Potapchik E., Shishkin S., Richardson E., Vacroux A., and Mathivet B. Russian Federation: Health System Review. Health Systems in Transition, 2011, vol. 13, no. 7.
30. Rice T., Rosenau P., Unruh L. Y., Barnes A. J., Van Ginneken E. United States of America: Health System Review. Health Systems in Transition, 2020, vol. 22, no. 4.
31. Rosen B., Waitzberg R., Merkur S. Israel: Health System Review. Health Systems in Transition, 2015, vol. 17, no. 6.
32. Rothgang H., Cacace M., Frisina L., Grimmeisen S., Schmid A., Wendt C. The State and Healthcare: Comparing OECD Countries. London, Palgrave Macmillan, 2010.
33. Rothgang H., Cacace M., Grimmeisen S., Wendt C. The Changing Role of the State in Healthcare Systems. European Review, 2005, vol. 13, no. 1, pp. 187-212.
34. Sheiman I. Forming the System of Health Insurance in the Russian Federation. Social Science and Medicine, 1994, vol. 39, no. 10, pp. 1425-1432.
35. Saltman R. B., Busse R., Figueras J. (eds). Social Health Insurance Systems in Western Europe. Maidenhead, Open University Press, 2004.
36. Twigg J. L. Russian Health Care Reform at the Regional Level: Status and Impact. Post Soviet Geography and Economics, 2001, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 202-219.
37. Van de Ven W., Beck K., Buchner F., Schokkaert E., Schut F. T. E., Shmueli A., Wasem Yu. Preconditions for Efficiency and Affordability in Competitive Health Markets: Are They Fulfilled in Belgium, Germany, Israel, the Netherlands and Switzerland? Health Policy, 2013, vol. 109. no. 3, pp. 226-245.
38. Van Ginneken E., Waitzberg R., Barnes A., Quentin W., Smatana M., Rice T. Choosing Payers: Can Insurance Competition Strengthen Person-Centred Care? In: Nolte E., Merkur S., Anell A. (eds.). Achieving PersonCentred Health Systems. Evidence, Strategies and Challenges. WHO Observatory on Health Systems and Health Reforms. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2020, pp. 229-258.
39. Xu W., Sheiman I., Van de Ven W., Zhang W. Prospects for Regulated Competition in the Health Care System: What Can China Learn From Russia’s Experience? Health Policy and Planning, 2011, vol. 26, no. 3, pp. 199-209.
Review
For citations:
Shishkin S.V. Evolution and Prospects of Compulsory Health Insurance in Russia. Economic Policy. 2023;18(1):8-33. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.18288/1994-5124-2023-1-8-33
Views:
643
Email this article 