The Cameralism of Peter I’s Administrative Reforms: Pro et Contra
https://doi.org/10.18288/1994-5124-2023-1-78-105
Abstract
The common view that Peter the Great’s administrative reforms were largely borrowed from primarily Swedish European practices and resembled the seventeenth-century kinds of governance associated with cameralism provides this study’s starting point. The article describes how the reform process that introduced the collegia unfolded and amounted to a true bureaucratic revolution with fully elaborated paperwork and regulations. Reconstructing the legislative processes of these reforms helps in understanding the extent to which they were borrowed and the way they differed from European prototypes.
The article’s main objective is to show the variety of methods employed to argue for cameralist features in Peter’s administrative reforms, as well as to identify the advantages and disadvantages of a broad and narrow way of interpreting them.
The broad interpretation of cameralism offers discourse about its striking resemblance to the spirit and tone of modernization but does not invoke any specific influences. This logic of historical elective affinity between phenomena is in the end too simplistic and may result in invalid conclusions. The paper maintains that it is more valuable to identify causal relationships and direct paths of influence. An example of this approach can be seen in Claes Peterson’s historical reconstruction, which clearly demonstrates how the ideas of the seventeenth-century cameralists Schroeder and Seckendorff were applied in Sweden’s regulations. This is the kind of diligent work that can firmly establish a connection between cameralism and the reforms. Broad generalizations capture only the most general features of the era and render the content of the term “cameralism” meaningless.
About the Author
D. Е. Raskov
University of Helsinki
Finland
Finland
Danila Е. Raskov, Cand. Sci. (Econ.), Research Fellow
Helsinki Collegium for Advanced Studies
00014; 24, Fabianinkatu; Helsinki
References
1. Anisimov E. V. Gosudarstvennye preobrazovaniya i samoderzhavie Petra Velikogo v pervoy chetverti XVIII veka [Peter the Great’s Transformation of the State and Autocracy in the First Quarter of the Eighteenth Century]. Saint Petersburg, Dmitriy Bulanin, 1997. (In Russ.)
2. Bagger H. Reformy Petra Velikogo: Obzor issledovaniy [Peter the Great’s Reform : Review of Research]. Trans. from Danish by V. E. Vozgrin. Moscow, Progress, 1985. (In Russ.)
3. Berendts E. Baron A. Kh. f. Lyuberas i ego zapiska ob ustroystve kollegiy v Rossii [Baron A. H. von Luberas and His Note on the Organization of the Collegia in Russia]. Saint Petersburg, Tipo-lit. R. Golike, 1891. (In Russ.)
4. Berendts E. Neskol’ko slov o «Kollegiyakh» Petra Velikogo [A Few Remarks on Peter the Great's “Collegia”]. Yaroslavl, Falk, 1896. (In Russ.)
5. Bobrova E. I. (comp.), Likhacheva D. S. (ed.). Biblioteka Petra I : ukazatel’-spravochnik [Peter the Great’s Library: Reference Index]. Leningrad, RAS Library, 1978. (In Russ.)
6. Bugrov K. D., Kiselev M. A. Estestvennoe pravo i dobrodetel’: Integratsiya evropeyskogo vliyaniya v rossiyskuyu politicheskuyu kul’turu XVIII veka [Natural Law and Virtue: Integration of European Influence in Eighteenth-Century Russian Political Culture]. Ekaterinburg, UrFU Publishing House, 2016. (In Russ.)
7. Voskresenskiy N. A. Petr Velikiy kak zakonodatel’. Issledovanie zakonodatel’nogo protsessa v Rossii v epokhu reform pervoy chetverti XVIII veka [Peter the Great as a Legislator: A Study of the Legislative Process in Russia During the Period of Reforms in the First Quarter of the Eighteenth Century]. Moscow, NLO, 2017. (In Russ.)
8. Dubyanskiy A. N. Idei kameralizma v ekonomicheskoy politike E. F. Сanсrina [The Ideas of Cameralism in the Economic Policy of E. F. Сanсrin]. Terra Economicus, 2019, vol. 17, no. 4, pp. 95-112. (In Russ.)
9. Voskresenskiy N. A. (comp.). ZA. Zakonodatel’nye akty Petra I. Redaktsii i proekty zakonov, zametki, doklady, donosheniya, chelobit’ya i inostrannye istochniki. T. 1: Akty o vysshikh gosudarstvennykh ustanovleniyakh [The Legislative Acts of Peter the Great. Editions and Drafts of Laws, Notes, Reports, Memoranda, Letters of Commendation, and Foreign Sources. Vol. 1: Acts of the Highest State Institutions]. Moscow, Leningrad, Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR, 1945. (In Russ.)
10. Voskresenskiy N. A. (comp.). ZA. Zakonodatel’nye akty Petra I. Redaktsii i proekty zakonov, zametki, doklady, donosheniya, chelobit’ya i inostrannye istochniki. T. 2: Akty ob obshchestvennykh aktakh. T. 3: Akty o promyshlennosti i torgovle [The Legislative Acts of Peter the Great: Editions and Drafts of Laws, Notes, Reports, Memoranda, Letters of Commendation, and Foreign Sources. Vol. 2: Acts of Public Acts. Vol. 3: Acts on Industry and Commerce]. Moscow, Drevlekhranilishche, 2020. (In Russ.)
11. Kamenskiy A. B. Ot Petra I do Pavla I [From Peter the Great to Paul I]. Saint Petersburg, Nauka, 2019. (In Russ.)
12. Lvova D. A. Vozniknovenie teorii kameral’noy bukhgalterii [Development of the Theory of Cameral Accounting]. Vestnik SPbGU. Seriya: Ekonomika [Saint Petersburg University Journal of Economic Studies, Economics Series], 2016, no. 1, pp. 56-79. (In Russ.)
13. Milyukov P. N. Gosudarstvennoe khozyaystvo Rossii v pervoy chetverti XVIII stoletiya i reforma Petra Velikogo [Russian State Economy in the First Quarter of the Eighteenth Century and the Reform of Peter the Great]. 2<sup>nd</sup> ed. Saint Petersburg, Tip. M. M. Stasyulevicha, 1905. (In Russ.)
14. Omelchenko N. A. «Kameralizm» ili «patriomonializm»: u istokov Petrovskoy reformatsii vysshego upravleniya v Rossii [“Cameralism” or “Patriomonialism”: At the Origins of Peter’s Reforms of Higher Administration in Russia]. Vestnik Universiteta, 2021, no. 9, pp. 21-27. (In Russ.)
15. Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiyskoy imperii. Sobranie Pervoe: S 1649 po 12 dekabrya 1825 g. : v 45 t. T. 5: 1713-1719 [The Complete Collection of Laws of the Russian Empire. First Collection: From 1649 to December 12, 1825. In 45 Vols. Vol. 5: 1713-1719]. Saint Petersburg, Printing House of the Second Department of His Imperial Majesty’s Own Chancellery, 1830. (In Russ.)
16. Raskov D. E. Kameralizm knig: perevody Justi v Rossii XVIII veka [Cameralism of Books: Translations of Justi in Eighteenth-Century Russia]. Terra Economicus, 2019, vol. 17, no. 4, pp. 62-79. (In Russ.)
17. Redin D. A. Ocharovanie “regulyarstva”: eshche raz o «Mental’nom gosudarstve» Petra Velikogo. Ch. 2: Rossiyskoe imperskoe gosudarstvo [The Allure of “Regularity”: Once Again on the “Mental State” of Peter the Great. Part 2: The Russian Imperial State]. Dialog so vremenem [Dialogue with Time], 2021, no. 75, pp. 315-334. (In Russ.)
18. Rudnev D. V. Yazyk General’nogo Reglamenta 1720 goda (k 300-letiyu pervogo izdaniya) [The Language of the General Regulation of 1720 (On the 300<sup>th</sup> Anniversary of Its First Publication)]. Sibirskiy filologicheskiy zhurnal [Siberian Journal of Philology], 2022, no. 1, pp. 178-191. (In Russ.)
19. Serov D. O. Sudebnaya reforma Petra I: istoriko-pravovoe issledovanie [The Judicial Reform of Peter I: Historical and Legal Studies]. Moscow, Zertsalo-M, 2009. (In Russ.)
20. Fedyukin I. Prozhektery: politika shkol’nykh reform v Rossii v pervoy polovine XVIII veka [The Enterprisers: The Politics of School in Early Modern Russia]. Trans. from Eng. Moscow, NLO, 2020. (In Russ.)
21. Chaplygina I. Kameralizm i universitetskie nauki v Moskovskom universitete XVIII veka [Cameralism and University Sciences at the University of Moscow in the Eighteenth Century]. Terra Economicus, 2019, vol. 17, no. 4, pp. 8-22. (In Russ.)
22. Almqvist D. Feifs Financiella Reformer och Wilhelm von Schröders “Fürstliche Schatzund Rent-Cammer”. Karolinska förbundets årsbok. Stockholm, 1922, s. 233-253.
23. Bartlett R. Cameralism in Russia: Empress Catherine II and Population Policy. In: Seppel M., Tribe K. (eds.). Cameralism in Practice: State Administration and Economy in Early Modern Europe. Woodbridge, Boydell Press, 2017, pp. 65-90.
24. Becher J. J. Närrische Weisheit und weise Narrheit. Frankfurt, Zubrod, 1683.
25. Cantselie Ordningh. In: Styffe C. G. (ed.). Samling af Instructioner rörande den civila förvaltningen i Sverige och Finnland. Stockholm, Hörbergska Boktryckriet, 1856, s. 327-365.
26. Cracraft J. The Petrine Revolution in Russian Culture. Cambridge, Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2004.
27. Cunha A. M. Administrative Centralisation, Police Regulations and Mining Sciences as Channels for the Dissemination of Cameralist Ideas in the Iberian World. In: Seppel M., Tribe K. (eds.). Cameralism in Practice. Woodbridge, Boydell & Brewer, 2017, pp. 155-178.
28. Cunha A. M. Cameralist Ideas in Portuguese Enlightened Reformism: The Diplomat Rodrigo de Souza Coutinho and His Circuits of Intellectual Exchange. In: Nokkala E., Miller N. (eds.). Cameralism and the Enlightenment: Happiness, Governance and Reform in Transnational Perspective. New York, NY, London, Routledge, 2020, pp. 201-223.
29. De La Mare N. Traité de La Police, où l’on trouvera l’histoire de son etablissement, les fonctions et les prerogatives de ses magistrats, toutes les loix et tous les reglemens. Tome premier. Paris, 1707.
30. Luna-Fabritius A. Cameralism in Spain: Polizeywissenschaft and the Bourbon Reforms. In: Nokkala E., Miller N. (eds.). Cameralism and the Enlightenment: Happiness, Governance and Reform in Transnational Perspective. New York, NY, London, Routledge, 2020, pp. 245-266.
31. Peterson C. Peter the Great’s Administrative and Judicial Reforms: Swedish Antecedents and the Process of Reception. Stockholm, Nordiska Bokhandeln, 1979.
32. Platonova N. V. Peter’s the Great’s Government Reforms and Accounting Practice in Russia. Accounting History, 2009, vol. 14, no. 4, pp. 437-464.
33. Pososhkov I. T. The Book on Poverty and Wealth. Trans. by Vlasto A. P., Lewitter L. R. (eds.). London, Athlone Press, 1987.
34. Raeff M. The Well-Ordered Police State and the Development of Modernity in Seventeenth and Eighteenth Century Europe: An Attempt at a Comparative Approach. The American Historical Review, 1975, vol. 80, pp. 1221-1243.
35. Raeff M. The Well-Ordered Police State: Social and Institutional Change Through Law in the Germanies and Russia, 1600-1800. New Haven, CT, London, Yale University Press, 1983.
36. Raskov D. Cameralism in Eighteenth-Century Russia: Reform, Translations and Academic Mobility. In: Nokkala E., Miller N. (eds.). Cameralism and the Enlightenment: Happiness, Governance, and Reform in Transnational Perspective. New York, NY, London, Routledge, 2020, pp. 274-301.
37. Roscher W. Geschichte der Nationalökonomik in Deutschland. Munich, Oldenburg, 1874.
38. Schiera P. Il Cameralismo e l’assolutismo tedesco: Dall’arte di governo alle scienze dello stato. Milano, A. Giuffrè, 1968.
39. Seckendorff V. L. Teutscher Fürsten-Stat. Frankfurt, Götze, 1656.
40. Small A. The Cameralists: The Pioneers of German Social Polity. Chicago, The University of Chicago Press, 1909.
41. Voltaire. Histoire de l’empire de Russie sous Pierre le Grand. Amsterdam, 1764.
42. Wakefield A. Books, Bureaus, and the Historiography of Cameralism. European Journal of Law and Economics, 2005, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 311-320.
43. Zielenziger K. Die alten deutschen Kameralisten: Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der Nationalökonomie und zum Problem des Merkantilismus. Jena, Gustav Fischer, 1914.
Review
For citations:
Raskov D.Е. The Cameralism of Peter I’s Administrative Reforms: Pro et Contra. Economic Policy. 2023;18(1):78-105. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.18288/1994-5124-2023-1-78-105
Views:
131
Email this article 