Peter the Great’s Cameralism and Transformations in Finance and Accounting

   The Admiralty Regulations of 1722 reformed the administration of the Russian naval fleet and laid the foundation for the system of state accounting. Tsar Peter the Great initiated those reforms in order to create a modern fleet and in so doing developed a new accounting system.

   The aim of this study is to evaluate the success of the reforms from the viewpoint of finance and accounting.

   This article’s analysis of the financial and accounting system of the navy indicates that Peter’s economic policy required the state to intervene directly in economic life and use redundant, granular controls for regulating all economic activities. The accounting model introduced by the Regulations is examined in reference to primary sources in order to determine to what extent the economic doctrine of cameralism was incorporated into the practice of public administration. The study also maintains that, within the context of cameralism, Peter’s reforms of public administration and finance were quite rational from an accounting standpoint. The study delves into the emergence and theoretical foundations of what is termed cameralistic accounting, one of the most widespread and influential accounting concepts of its era. Although this concept (also referred to as a model, theory or paradigm) was widely used toward the end of the eighteenth century and even now persists in the public sector, its development and theoretical basis remain poorly understood. The study shows how effective the budgeting efforts inherent in cameralism were in the Russian state administration of the Petrine era and describes the role accounting played in this process.

1. Bauer O. O. Memuary k istorii bukhgalterii i pamyatniki svyashchennoy stariny [Memoirs in the History of Accounting and Monuments of Sacred Antiquity]. Moscow, 1911. (In Russ.)

2. Bogoslovskiy M. M. Oblastnaya reforma Petra Velikogo: provintsiya 1719-27 gg. [Regional Reform of Peter the Great: The Provinces in 1719-27]. Мoscow, Universitetskaya tipografiya, 1902. (In Russ.)

3. Voskresenskiy N. A. Petr Velikiy kak zakonodatel’. Issledovanie zakonodatel’nogo protsessa v Rossii v epokhu reform pervoy chetverti XVIII veka [Peter the Great as a Legislator: A Study of the Legislative Process in Russia During the Era of Reforms in the First Quarter of the XVIII Century]. Мoscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2017. (In Russ.)

4. Galagan A. M. Schetovodstvo v ego istoricheskom razvitii [The Historical Development of Accounting]. Мoscow, Leningrad, Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo, 1927. (In Russ.)

5. Goltsev V. A. Gosudarstvennoe khozyaystvo vo Frantsii XVII v. Istoricheskiy ocherk [The State Economy of France in the XVII Century: A Historical Essay]. Мoscow, Tip. K. Indrikha, 1878. (In Russ.)

6. Zhitkov K. G. Istoriya russkogo flota. Period Petrovskiy. 1672-1725 [History of the Russian Fleet: The Petrine Era 1672-1725]. Saint Petersburg, Publication of the Count S. A. Stroganov Commission for Management of Capital, 1912. (In Russ.)

7. Instruktsiya knyazya M. M. Shcherbatova prikazchikam ego yaroslavskikh votchin (1758 g. s dobavleniyami k ney po 1762 g.) [Instruction of Prince M. M. Shcherbatov to the Clerks of His Yaroslavl Estates (1758 With Addenda Through 1762)]. In: Materialy po istorii sel’skogo khozyaystva i krest'yanstva SSSR [Historical Materials on Agriculture and Farmers in the USSR]. Moscow, Nauka, 1965. Vol. VI. (In Russ.)

8. Istomina N. A. Opyt tsentralizovannogo byudzhetnogo planirovaniya pri Petre I - sostavlenie byudzheta 1710 g. [The Experience of Centralized Budget Planning Under Peter the Great: Preparation of the Budget for 1710]. Finansy i kredit [Finance and Credit], 2012, no. 30(510), pp. 78-82. (In Russ.)

9. Kallistov N. D. Organizatsiya i rezul’taty deyatel’nosti flota pri Petre Velikom [Organization and Results of Naval Activity Under Peter the Great]. In: Istoriya russkoy armii i flota [History of the Russian Army and Navy]. Moscow, Russian Association Printing House, 1912, pp. 140-145. (In Russ.)

10. Klyuchevskiy V. O. Kurs russkoy istorii. Ch. IV [Russian History Course: Part IV]. Moscow, Sotsekgiz, 1937. (In Russ.)

11. Kommercheskiy kodeks Frantsii : V 2 t. [French Commercial Code. In 2 Vols.]. Trans. by Zakhvataev V. N. Moscow, Wolters Kluver, 2008. Vol. 1. (In Russ.)

12. Lebedev A. I. Flot pri blizhayshikh preemnikakh Petra Velikogo. 1725-1761 gg. [The Fleet Under Peter the Great’s Immediate Successors]. In: Istoriya russkoy armii i flota [History of the Russian Army and Navy]. Moscow, Obrazovanie, 1912. (In Russ.)

13. Mazdorov V. A. Istoriya razvitiya bukhgalterskogo ucheta v SSSR (1917-1972) [History of the Development of Accounting in the USSR (1917-1972)]. Moscow, Finansy, 1972. (In Russ.)

14. Manvelov N. V. Obychai i traditsii Rossiyskogo Imperatorskogo flota [Customs and Traditions of the Russian Imperial Navy]. Moscow, Yauza, Eksmo, 2008.

15. Materialy dlya istorii russkogo flota [Materials in the History of the Russian Fleet]. Saint Petersburg, Maritime Ministry Printing House, 1867. (In Russ.)

16. Milyukov P. N. Gosudarstvennoe khozyaystvo Rossii v pervoy chetverti XVIII stoletiya i reforma Petra Velikogo [The State Economy of Russia in the First Quarter of the Eighteenth Century and the Reform of Peter the Great]. 2^nd ed. Saint Petersburg, Tip. M. M. Stasyulevicha, 1905. (In Russ.)

17. Pavlenko N. I. Petr I (K izucheniyu sotsial’no-politicheskikh vzglyadov) [Peter the Great (Toward the Study of Socio-Political Views)]. In: Rossiya v period reform Petra I [Russia During Peter the Great’s Reforms]. Moscow, Nauka, 1973. (In Russ.)

18. Picheta V. Reforma armii i flota pri Petre Velikom [Reform of the Army and Navy Under Peter the Great]. In: Kallash V. V. (ed.) Tri veka. Rossiya ot Smuty do nashego vremeni : istoricheskiy sbornik. V 6 t. [Three Centuries: Russia From the Time of Troubles to the Present : A Historical Collection. In 6 Vols.]. Vol. 3-4. Мoscow, GIS-Patriot, Detektiv, 1992. (In Russ.)

19. Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiyskoy imperii. Sobranie Pervoe: S 1649 po 12 dekabrya 1825 g. V 45 t. [The Complete Collection of Laws of the Russian Empire. First Collection: From 1649 to December 12, 1825. In 45 Vols.]. Saint Petersburg, Printing House of the Second Department of His Imperial Majesty’s Own Chancellery, 1830a. Vol. 6: 1720-1722. (In Russ.)

20. Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiyskoy imperii. Sobranie Pervoe: S 1649 po 12 dekabrya 1825 g. : V 45 t. T. 5: 1713-1719 [The Complete Collection of Laws of the Russian Empire. First Collection: From 1649 to December 12, 1825. In 45 Vols.]. Saint Petersburg, Printing House of the Second Department of His Imperial Majesty’s Own Chancellery, 1830b. Vol. 9: 1733-1736. (In Russ.)

21. Reglament o upravlenii Admiralteystva i verfi i o dolzhnostyakh kollegii admiralteyskoy i prochikh vsekh chinov pri Admiralteystve obretayushchikhsya [Regulations on the Management of the Admiralty and Shipyard and on the Positions of the Admiralty Board and All Other Ranks Under the Admiralty]. Saint Petersburg, 1722. (In Russ.)

22. Sakovich V. A. Gosudarstvennyy kontrol’ v Rossii, ego istoriya i sovremennoe ustroystvo v svyazi s izlozheniem smetnoy sistemy, kassovogo poryadka i ustroystva gosudarstvennoy otchetnosti. Ch. 1 [State Control in Russia, Its History and Modern Structure in Relation to the Elaboration of the Estimate System, Cash Procedure and State Reporting Structure: Part 1]. Saint Petersburg, Tipo-litografiya Berman i Rabinovich, 1896-1897. (In Russ.)

23. Skobara V., Telepneva A. Gosudarstvennyy finansovyy kontrol’ v sisteme upravleniya gosudarstvom [State Financial Control in the State Administration System]. Moscow, Nauchnaya biblioteka, 2013. (In Russ.)

24. Sokolov Ya. V. Bukhgalterskiy uchet: ot istokov, do nashikh dney [Accounting: From Its Origins to the Present]. Moscow, Audit, YuNITI, 1996. (In Russ.)

25. Sokolov Ya. V. Osnovy teorii bukhgalterskogo ucheta. [Fundamentals of Accounting Theory]. Moscow, Finansy i statistika, 2000. (In Russ.)

26. Sokolov Ya. V. Ocherki po istorii bukhgalterskogo ucheta [Essays on Accounting History]. Moscow, Finansy i statistika, 1991. (In Russ.)

27. Solovev S. M. Sochineniya: V 18 kn. [Works in 18 Books]. Kn. VIII. T. 15-16: Istoriya Rossii s drevneyshikh vremen [Book VIII, vols. 15-16: History of Russia From Ancient Times]. Мoscow, Golos, Kolokol-Press, 1997. (In Russ.)

28. Ustav o voyskakh morskikh i o ikh arsenalakh. Lyudovika chetvertogo na desyat’ korolya Frantsuzskogo i Navarskogo. Napechatalsya poveleniem Tsarskogo Velichestva [Charter on Naval Troops and Their Arsenals: Louis the Fourth Through Ten Kings of France and Navarre. Printed by Command of His Royal Majesty]. Saint Petersburg, 1715. (In Russ.)

29. Khitrovo V. N. Bukhgalteriya v primenenii k gosudarstvennym oborotam [Accounting as Applied to State Transactions]. Saint Petersburg, Maritime Minstry Printing House, 1860. (In Russ.)

30. Chaadaev P. Ya. Apologiya sumasshedshego [Apology of the Madman]. In: Gershenzon O. M. (ed.). Voprosy filosofii i psikhologii [Problems in Philosophy and Psychology]. 1906. Book 4(84). (In Russ.)

31. Shirokiy V. F. Istoriko-ekonomicheskoe issledovanie materialov khozyaystvennogo ucheta v Rossii XVIII v. Zakonodatel’nye akty i literaturnye istochniki : dis. ... kand. nauk [Historical and Economic Study of Economic Accounting Materials in Eighteenth-Century Russia: Legislative Acts and Literary Sources : PhD Thesis]. Saint Petersburg, Rossiyskaya natsional’naya biblioteka, 1939. (In Russ.)

32. Filios V. The Cameralist Method of Accounting: А Historical Note. Journal of Business, Finance and Accounting, 1983, vol. 10, no. 3, pp. 443-450.

33. Legay M.-L. The Beginnings of Public Management: Administrative Science and Political Choices in the Eighteenth Century in France, Austria, and the Austrian Netherlands. The Journal of Modern History, 2009, no. 81, pp. 253-293.

34. Monsen N. The Case for Cameral Accounting. Financial Accountability & Management, 2002, vol. 18, no. 1, pp. 39-72.

35. Peterson C. Peter the Great’s Administrative and Judicial Reforms: Swedish Antecedents and the Process of Reception. Stockholm, Nordiska Bokhandeln, 1979, pp. 7-8.

36. Rössner P. R. Freedom and Capitalism in Early Modern Europe. Palgrave Macmillan, 2020.

37. Small A. W. The Cameralists: The Pioneers of German Social Polity. New York, NY, 1909.

38. Ten Have O. Simon Stevin of Bruges. In: Littleton A. C., Yamey B. S. (eds.). Studies in the History of Accounting. London, Sweet & Maxwell, 1956.

39. Vlaemminck J. H. Histoire et Doctrines de la comptabilité. Paris, Editions Pragnos, 1956.

40. Volmer F. Stevin, Simon (1548-1620). In: Chatfield M., Vangermeersch R. (eds.). The History of Accounting: An International Encyclopedia. London, New York, NY, Garland Publishing, Inc., 1996.

41. Wakefield A. The Disordered Police State: German Cameralism as Science and Practice. London, Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 2009.